If you look at the stats for Michigan State's 70-69 win over Tennessee, you'll see that they were about as close as the score was.
The Vols shot 24-of-48 from the field (7-of-16 from 3-point range), the Spartans shot 24-of-52 (6-of-18 from 3-point range). Tennessee was 14-of-21 on free throws, while Michigan State went 16-of-21 from the charity line. On the glass, each team had 24 rebounds. Both teams were also careful with the ball, giving up just 10 turnovers each.
On paper, it was close. Really close. Yet the Spartans are the ones wearing the Final Four hats and t-shirts, hoisting up the regional championship trophy and getting the CBS post-game interviews, while the Vols sat with their heads in their hands, reliving each moment that could have gone the other way and maybe changed the outcome of the game.
You could blame Brian Williams for missing two free throws that would have tied the game with less than five minutes left. You could blame the refs for missing some foul calls on Michigan State in the paint. You could blame J.P. Prince for getting two fouls in three seconds, leading to an 8-1 run by the Spartans while he was on the bench.
The fact of the matter is that each of the nine Vols who took shots during the game missed at least one. That's pretty much how it goes in every game at any level. Unnecessary analysis of every play is pointless, especially since the game is over.
If you're looking for the real reason why the Vols lost, look no further than Michigan State head coach Tom Izzo.
In 15 seasons as the head coach, Izzo has accumulated a 363-144 record and taken the Spartans to 13 straight NCAA Tournaments. In his fourth season, he led Michigan State to its first Final Four since 1979, and the Spartans won the national championship the next season. Since winning the national title, Izzo has made it back to four Final Fours, including a championship game appearance last season.
Izzo has a strong argument to say he's the best coach in the country. Saying the Vols didn't win because of avoidable mistakes is just getting it wrong, because it degrades Izzo and his team of their accomplishment. They advanced two rounds without starting point guard Kalin Lucas, who led the team in scoring this season.
Against a Vols team that had dominated its past two opponents inside the paint, Izzo hit the mark on his defensive strategy. Michigan State made a non-factor out of Wayne Chism, who terrorized Ohio State inside in the Sweet 16, holding him to just three points in the second half. The Spartans held their ground in the paint, forcing the Vols to play on the perimeter for much of the game.
When the game came down to the wire, it was clear that Izzo and his players had been there before, and UT head coach Bruce Pearl and the Vols had not.
On the last Michigan State possession after Scotty Hopson made one of two free throws to tie the game, there was apparent confusion about defensive assignments, forcing Prince to bite the bullet and commit a foul with two seconds left. When the Vols had 1.6 seconds left to inbound the ball and get a 3-point attempt, they completely botched the play when Prince, a not-so-adept long-range shooter, took a half-court shot that was nowhere close to the rim.
Maybe the players didn't execute instructions, but blame ends up falling on Pearl. However, he shouldn't have to face too much fire. After all, he did just deliver Tennessee's first Elite Eight appearance and nearly had them in the Final Four as a six-seed.
The Vols survived a scare against San Diego State, found their stride against Ohio, held on to beat a national player of the year in Evan Turner and Ohio State, then stayed close and played a solid brand of basketball against an elite defensive team in Michigan State, all while several people picked UT to lose in the first-round.
There's no shame in putting forth true effort and coming up short. No shame at all.
Sometimes the ball just doesn't bounce your way.